Friday, February 12, 2010

Dreamland as Pakistan

1. Subj: Dailypioneer.com - Dreamland as Pakistan
2. My Take:

Is Pakistan a dreamland, a land of dreams ?


Answer: Pakistan is not a dream, it is a nightmare ! It is frightening.& horrid.

Surinder Paul Attri

Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Dog-Gone Doniger

1. Namaste Attri Ji,
Does it not seem that the western people are in arrested development mentally & psychologically? If measured by their oh so favorite Freud who they use so "intelligently" to discredit us, they (the entire "western christian (especially white) culture" is stuck in the Oral-Anal-Phallic phase of development, &c are so happy there that they don't want to move forward? For moving forward to the next level will mean accepting their own fallacies & deceptions.

Namaste.
Poonam

2. My Take:
Namaste Poonam Jee:
Quote: they (the entire "western christian (especially white) culture" is stuck in the Oral-Anal-Phallic phase of development.

COMMENT: This is Freudian stuff. They refer to it as the Oedipal phase. Un-successful resolution of this phase, is said to result in several mental diseases. Individuals who have unsuccessful resolution of this phase are said, to be afflicted with Oedipus-Complex.

The West does seem to have a run-in with the Freudian-Complex. Possibly, that is why there is so much unconscious guilt in the West.

3. Quote: If measured by their oh so favorite Freud who they use so "intelligently" to discredit us,

COMMENT: I do not want to play psychiatry, but it might not be too far-fetched to suspect that, they ( that is, the West ) by running down others ( throwing them in the dumpster ), might provide them with some measure of relief, from the painful memories of their childhood ( the oedipal-phase ), when emotions are running high.

4. Quote: are so happy there that they don't want to move forward? For moving forward to the next level will mean accepting their own fallacies & deceptions.

COMMENT: It is not easy to move forward when, individuals are in the clutches of Oedipus-Comples. That possibly undermines the capacity to move forward.

Surinder Paul Attri

Tuesday, February 2, 2010

Dog-Gone Doniger

1. MONDAY, FEBRUARY 1, 2010

DONIGER DOES DOGGIE?
Doniger Does Doggie

by

Shrinivas Tilak

Let me begin with a clarification of the title, which was suggested by an “adult” film that had gained certain notoriety back in the 1970s. Called, “Debbie Does Dallas,” the film depicted exploits of a sex worker named Debbie with members of a professional sports team based in Dallas, Texas. I did not see the film but recollect from the newspaper accounts of the time that colloquially, the ‘doggie’ trick alludes to one of the more popular ‘positions’ in the sex act.

‘Doniger’ in the title refers to Wendy Doniger, who is the Mircea Eliade Distinguished Service Professor of the History of Religion at the University of Chicago. The connection between ‘Debbie’ of the film and Professor Wendy Doniger (hereafter Doniger) is that they both are in the business of providing entertainment involving sex. Both employ bodies: Debbie her own; and Doniger the bodies of Hindu gods and goddesses.

Dogs (along with horses and cows) loom large in Doniger’s latest work. The index contains a dozen or so entries under the main heading of dogs for instance. The 779 pages book is officially entitled, “The Hindus: An Alternative History” (New York: The Penguin Press, 2009; hereafter The Hindus). In Doniger’s ‘alternative history’ (in reality it is more like a work of fiction and not at all a history) unfolding India and Hinduism, "dogs" represent "high caste Hindu males" who have according to her oppressed and repressed everybody else in India since the ancient Vedic times. In Doniger’s reckoning, the traditional history of India (“a product of Brahmin imagination”), religious minorities and social outcastes are reduced to a status of a ‘scape-dog’ (or are they all underdogs) (p. 145) (these underdogs include Muslims who ruled over the Hindus and controlled territory larger than currently recognized as India for most of the last millennium; I told you this is a work of fiction!)

The main purpose of The Hindus, accordingly, is to provide a narrative account of alternative people who do not figure in the Brahmin-generated history — people who are "alternative" in the sense of "otherness," people of other religions, or cultures, or castes, or species (even animals)(p.1). Having read The Hindus from cover to cover, I can say that Doniger lives up to her promise but at a terrible cost for Hindus and India.

Under the guise of providing an alternative history, the real nefarious agenda of The Hindus is to drive a wedge between Hindus and non-Hindus in India and elsewhere. In order to show how Hindus are so utterly unlike others Doniger engages in denigrating, distorting, and demeaning all Hindus (low or high caste, men or women) and what is worse, ‘defrocking’ (both theologically and sexually) their gods and goddesses.

Selectively picking mythic episodes (stories) from the Purana and the Tantra texts Doniger describes relations between gods and gods, between gods and goddesses, between goddesses and animals. Here, a god beheads another god; there, a goddess ‘hooks up’ with a buffalo [demon] and so on. See for instance chapter
14,‘Goddesses and Gods in the Early Puranas’ and chapter 15 ‘Sects and Sex in the Tantric Puranas and the Tantras.’

I will leave it to professional psychiatrists (like Dr. Shreekumar Vinekar) to analyze and interpret Doniger’s preoccupation with sex and pervert joy she finds in abstracting from Hindu myths sexual encounters (natural and ‘unnatural’) between gods/goddesses and humans or animals. Doniger claims that she is a ‘recovering Orientalist.’ Orientalism, she asserts, refers to a cluster of attitudes that implicated the first European scholars of India in the European colonization of India, overwhelming reliance on textual studies being one of them, pp.34-35). In truth, Doniger seems to have added a sexual dimension to the textual one in her so called studies of India and Hinduism.

Elsewhere Doniger does betray an awareness that Hindu views of animals are far more complex to capture by words like “sacred” or “impure.” Other people’s zoological taxonomies look bizarre only to people who view them through their own rather ethnocentric lenses (p. 659). The fact is: Doniger continues to look at all Hindu taxonomies through her unique ethnocentric lens.

Here, I will deal with two specific instances where Doniger clearly abandons the role of an unbiased, academic historian. While discussing the Taj Mahal in chapter 24‘The Past in the Present’ she claims, “One advocate of Hindutva has argued, on the basis of absolutely no evidence, that the Taj Mahal, in Agra, is not a [sic] Islamic mausoleum but an ancient Shiva temple…"(p. 679). Doniger herself does not bring any clear evidence for her assertion that the Taj Mahal is an Islamic mausoleum nor does she refer to any legitimate archeological study of Taj Mahal. To date, the Archaeological Survey of India has not carried out a systematic survey of the Taj Mahal. Doniger does not mention P. N. Oak by name (the end note does provide reference to his book Taj Mahal: The True Story, 1989). There is growing evidence suggesting that it is still not clear who actually built the Taj Mahal or what its purpose was (see my blog “P. N. Oak: the lone fighter, etymologist, and historian” on www.sulekha.com for details).

After 686 pages, comes chapter 25 ‘In Conclusion, or, The Abuse of History,’ which is only 3 1/ 2 pages long! It begins with a long quotation attributed to Madhav Sadashiv Golwalkar (1906-1973) who, claims Doniger, used the justifiable Hindu pride in religious tolerance to justify intolerance (p. 687). I have seen this quotation attributed to Golwalkar in dozens of so-called scholarly monographs by Western and Indian academics, historians, and Indologists who conveniently create a ‘straw-man’ out of Golwalkar as an iconic Hindu fanatic.

Like others Doniger demonizes Golwalkar and his thought as intolerant on the basis of just one paragraph from a small pamphlet "We, Our Nationhood Defined" (p 48-49). This is unhistorical, besides being incompetent and biased scholarship considering the fact that Golwalkar only translated that work into Hindi, originally written in Marathi by Balarao Savarkar, the younger brother of Vinayak D. Savarkar. It does not necessarily mean that Golwalkar, as the translator, endorsed or espoused all the ideas presented by Balarao Savarkar. Furthermore, Golwalkar was active in India’s public life thirty-five years after the pamphlet came out and his collected works run up to thousands of printed pages collected in twelve volumes. One would expect a more nuanced assessment of Golwalkar from “one of the foremost scholars of Hinduism in the world" as claimed in the blurb. Those interested in an ‘alternative’ perspective on Golwalkar may consult my "Reawakening to a secular Hindu nation: M. S. Golwalkar’s vision of a dharmasapeksha Hindurashtra" (Charleston, SC: Book Surge Publications, 2008).

In sum, those who will rely on "The Hindus" to learn about Hindus in the history of India will do so at their own peril.
2.My Take:
Subject: Dog-Gone Doniger
There is one thing that, Dog-Gone Doniger ( Wendy Doniger ) does better than any one else, and that is, how to give Hell to Hindus.
We Hindus are Not perfect, but we are savagely hit, again & again by fake historians like Dog-Gone Doniger. For them, anything that is Anti-Hindu, is secualr, open, and fair. The elaborate hoax of her book: " Hindus: An Alternative History, " only pleases Anti-Hindus, and brings havoc upon the Hindu.

3. The title of her book is: Hindus: An alternative history. What history ? This is no history & she is no historian. She is a fiction writer, and her mission is demolition ( Hinduism Demolition ). Her specialty is providing entertainment through sex, and her turret-gun is aimed straight at Hindu gods & goddesses. As a historian, she is a complete-wreck. Doniger's obsession with sex is serious, she derives some sick joy out of it. That is why she demonizes Hinduism royally, and runs all over it. That is what she does for fun.

4. There is no turning point for Dog-Gone Doniger, and there is no easy fix, the wheels of her brain would have to come off completely. She is a lost cause.

Hindus: If you are wondering where the enemy is, Dog-Gone Doniger is right up there, along with Moslems. Both complement each other very well. Both Moslems & Doniger want to tear down Hinduism, and that is a fact.

Surinder Paul Attri

Monday, February 1, 2010

Jyoti Basu, a great leader or a lousy anti-Hindu devil.

Jyoti Basu, a great leader or a lousy anti-Hindu devil.
By S.P. Attri ( USA )
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. The simple bare truth: Jyoti Basu has been dropping his mammoth payload of anti-Hinduism ( and anti-Indianism ) for decades. The swinish multitude of his ignoble-deeds, is a rough & rowdy, un-civilized dung-hill.
In 1947, he supported the partition of India, to create an anti-Hindu homeland for the Moslems of India, out of India, in the area now called Pakistan. In 1971, he stooped even lower, and went completely over-board. Bloated with Communist-certitude & proud as a peacock, Jyoti Basu refused to protest the slaughter of millions of East Pakistani Hindus, his own kind.

2. If Jyoti Basu had been loyal to Bengal & to India, he would have recommended that, India annex a fourth of East Pakistan,to settle the Hindu refugees ( more than 9 million of them ), more than 3 million of whom, were gunned down in East Pakistan during 1970 & 1971. But Jyoti Basu did no such thing, he did not even utter a word, to protest the barbaric actions of Pakistani-Government, against the East Pakistani Hindus. Jyoti Basu remains a memorial to Hindu-Horror in East Pakistan.

3. Does any action of Jyoti Basu inspire faith, among the great Hindu majority? Hell, No !
Jyoti Basu was an imbecile, and a traitor to the Hindu & to his Hinduism. He regarded Hinduism as the opium of the masses, and the non-sense that he floated in the air,was meant to fool the gullible Hindu population. How can Jyoti Basu hold his head high, in the face of such un-dignified ( infra digitatem ) attitude against the Hindu, by putting his forte in a napkin ?

4. Jyoti Basu was a Minister, but his actions were Sinister, and he was a Blister.
Moslems kill Hindus because, killing of Hindus is sanctified by Quran & Hadis. Communists ( Jyoti Basu's group ) kill Hindus because, they regard Hinduism as the opium of masses, and they are set against it. Their intention is to destroy Hinduism in India, in whole or in part, so that they can establish a so-called class-less & caste-less state, in their place. Both Islam & Communism are super-charged to wreck & ravage Hinduism in India.
This frightful truth ought to cause concern, among all Hindus all over ( In India as well in Diospora ).

5. What about Jyoti Basu's performance in West Bengal ?
Under his leadership, West Bengal became a cesspool of incompetence & corruption. He milked West Bengal for 30 years. Rather than the leader, he was the wrecker of West Bengal.
While Jyoti Basu was giving Hell to Hindus, Communist-China was having Hell Of A Joy.
Communists in general, and Jyoti Basu in particular, are the New Rakshishas of India. They have brought nothing but poverty, ignorance, and corruption into our Indian system. They have stolen our dreams, made our Hindu voice irrelevent, now they want to make us Hindus, refugees in our own land of Bharat Varsha.

6. Communists regard themselves as Reds. In India, they make Red with blood, the Hindu blood. They are barbarians, directionless, and appeal to some utopian peudo-concepts, which cannot be realized because,they are against the basic nature of man. Hindus ought to stop Human devils like Jyoti Basu. Instead of praising him, and treating him with kid-gloves, he ought to be damned, and given a no-bar, no-hold bashing.

Surinder Paul Attri

Sunday, January 10, 2010

Terrorists have no religion---Shah Rukh Khan

1. Terrorists have no religion---Shah Rukh Khan
Submitted by Mike Ghouse (United States), Jan 8, 2010 at 21:23
Surinder,
It is your choice to believe what the recycled hate material has been passed on for generations
Freedom of speech is one of the most important rights of humans which is valued by Muslims, Hindus, Christians, Jews and others who form over 95% of the people in their respective groups ([2:256]CC. There shall be no compulsion in religion: the right way is now distinct from the wrong way. Anyone who denounces the devil and believes in GOD has grasped the strongest bond; one that never breaks. GOD is Hearer, Omniscient. (My note to those with range of faith - devil broadly means evilness, God broadly means Goodness, balance and Harmony)
If you are talking about Necons (http://hatesermons.blogspot.com/2008/03/neocons.html ), they are a different breed, there is no freedom for them. A Muslim Neocon will pound another Muslim if he criticizes Sharia, but the majority has no problems. A Jewish man will be pounded and even declared a self-hating Jew if he criticizes Israel, but the majority of Jews have no problems. A Hindu will be pounded by the Hindutva Brigade if they criticize India or their hate policies…. I am talking about good to the bone Jews, Muslims, Hindus, Christians and others.
Think and write independently free from hate and bias. It is your choice to be full of hate and live the life or free yourselves from hate, ill will, malice, anger and enjoy the God given life.
2. My Take:
Quote: It is your choice to believe what the recycled hate material has been passed on for generations.
COMMENT:
Mike:
Advice on " freedom of speech , " plus " affection & amity, " coming from a Moslem such as you, whose workbook ( Quran ) is the Biggest Gospel Of Hate, is hollow & hypocritical howl. Fourteen hundred years of Islamic murder, mutilation, & demolition of Kafirs, speak oceans. Disgusting & distasteful to civilized nations, these acts are pretty & pleasing to Allah, in reward a Moslem gets seventy-two Houris ( doe-eyed maidens ), to satisfy his wildest sexual reveries.
3. Quote: Go sit with a few Muslim, join some discussion groups, join one of the largest Muslim groups that I run worldMuslimcongress-subscribe@yahoogroups.com .
COMMENT: I eschewed many such invitations in the past, because.
More I know Islam, Less I like it.
4. Quote: Freedom of speech is one of the most important rights of humans which is valued by Muslims.
COMMENT: Freedom Of Speech " DOES NOT BELONG IN ISLAM. " Islam views Democracy ( Freedom Of Speech included ), as an assault on Islam. Your contrary-claim is wide of the mark.
Numerous Islamic scholars, who deliberated on this, admitted incompatibility of Islam with Democracy. Their conclusion:
" The Democratic system that is prevalent in world, is not suitable, for our religion or our people. "
5. Quote: There shall be no compulsion in religion: the right way is now distinct from the wrong way.
COMMENT: Islam does not acknowledge, veracity of any other faith. It ardently desires to decimate all other faiths, along with their followers. Compulsion to convert Kafirs to Islam is " Profuse " in Islam. Nothing could be more off the mark, than your claim to the contrary.
" Brutalities committed by Moslems on Kafirs ( Non-Moslem Infidels ), who refused to accept Islam, are without parallel in human history. "
6. Quote: Anyone who denounces the devil and believes in GOD has grasped the strongest bond; one that never breaks.
COMMENT: Devil, a totally-imaginary entity, exists in & is denounced only by Abrahamic-Religions ( Islam, Christianity, & Judaism ). There is no Devil in Hinduism. Why should a Hindu hit at imaginary entities ? That is the specialty of Islam ( and other similar cults, who have received bum-dope ).
Contrasting Islamic-Devil ( Shaitaan ) against Islamic-God ( Allah ), Shaitaan comes out smelling like a rose. The blood-thirsty tribal chief, Allah, commands permanent slaughter, rape, pillage & plunder of Kafirs, for only crime of not believing in Him. Shaitaan, a totally dis-similar entity, does no such thing.
7. Quote: If you are talking about Necons(http://hatesermons.blogspot.com/2008/03/neocons.html ), they are a different breed, there is no freedom for them. A Muslim Neocon will pound another Muslim if he criticizes Sharia, but the majority has no problems.
COMMENT: Islam has distinction without Jehadic-Difference ( Kafir-Murder ), between Necons & Olcons. Both Necons & Olcons get to enjoy, choicest-sex after death.
A Moslem who criticizes Sharia ( laws on true way of life ) is a Heretic in Islam, and suffers the fate of a Hateful-Kafir, buttressing Equal Opportunity Barbarism of butcher- Islam.
8. Quote: A Jewish man will be pounded and even declared a self-hating Jew if he criticizes Israel, but the majority of Jews have no problems. A Hindu will be pounded by the Hindutva Brigade if they criticize India or their hate policies.
COMMENT Don't lump Hinduism, Judaism, & Islam together. they are not the same. Hinduism is Dharma and Islam certainly is not. Islam is something evil, its imperialist & political doctrine is lethal, it has done much damage to humanity. Its Quran-Sanctioned Kafir-Killing will continue, unless stopped.
9. Quote: I am talking about good to the bone Jews, Muslims, Hindus, Christians and others.
COMMENT: Good to the bone tenets of Islam are, bad & bigoted.
Islam is like Rooster-Cogburn:
" Bad to the Bone. "
Surinder Paul Attri

Friday, January 8, 2010

Terrorists have no religion...Shah Rukh Khan

Subj: Terrorists have no religion...Shah Rukh Khan
1. Surinder ji: Namaskar to you

No body except you can proffer such a cogent and logical argument. No rational person can stand before your argument. You have completely demolished the guy who is masquerading as secularists while hiding his real identity. Thanks again.

Narain Kataria

2. My Take:
Kataria Jee: Namaskar to you & thanks.
Right you are !
Signor Mike Ghouse's statements though addressed to Mr. Daniel Pipes, were meant for me, to bull-sh** me.

3. Mike Ghourse, a Moslem, whose religion/ideology rejects freedom of speech outright, is using " The Big Lie Technique. " Playing A Mean Fiddle, " he is attempting to hoodwink us Kafirs. Truth is exact opposite.

4. Recors of Islam's murder machine, of its mutilation, misery, & brutality on Kafirs, engraved on the pages of history, cannot be camouflaged. These expose Islam's Pitiless Prescription, which is that:

" Islam is the only true way of life: the rest ( that is, the Kafir/Non-Moslem religions ) are fake & foul, these must be eliminated, and Kafirs must be murdered or enslaved. "

A person cannot be a Moslem, without believing these commands of Islam.

5. . The unquestioned truth is that:
" Islam is the ideology of champion-barbarians." .

Surinder Paul Attri

Terrorists have no religion---Shah Rukh Khan is not telling the truth

Subj: Terrorists have no religion---Shah Rukh Khan is not telling the truth
1. Daniel,
I am for freedom of speech and that gives others the
freedom to say whatever they want, whether you said it or not.
YOu cannot stop any one from WMDing
Mike Ghouse
2. My Take:
Quote: I am for freedom of speech.
COMMENT: But if you are for freedom of speech, then why are you still in Islam. There is no freedom of speech in Islam. Islam is the Islam of Quran, a Brutal Gospel Of Hate ( Hatred Of Kafirs/Non-Moslem Infidels ). There neither is nor can there ever, be a freedom of speech in Quran.
3. By pledging freedom of speech, you will lose your identity as a Moslem. Worse yet, you may earn a Fatwa against you. Mullahs & Maulvies ( M & Ms ) will never recognize your right to substitute a Man-Made concept ( such as freedom of speech ), for Allah-Commanded book of Quran.

4. Quran does permit Taqiyya to a Moslem. Quran is against believers ( Moslems ) deceiving ( lying to ) other believers ( Moslems ), but deception ( lying ) directed at Non-Moslems ( Kafirs ), known as Taqiyya, is O.K. and has Quranic support.

5. Other than Quran-commanded Taqiyya, Moslems have no freedom of speech. Their lie to Kafirs ( Non-Moslem Infidels ), is Diligent-Jehad in the name of Allah.
Total-collapse of freedom of speech in Islam, is obligatory on a Moslem.

Surinder Paul Attri